Listen Now
Hosted by Rev. Enger Muteteke
Senior Director of Programs and Education at GCORR
Featuring Rev. Zach Anderson
District Superintendent in the Great Plains Conference of The United Methodist Church and Member of the GCORR Board
Introduction
What happens when our national identity becomes intertwined with our Christian faith? How do we distinguish between loyalty to our country and our calling to follow Jesus?
In our first episode, Rev. Zach Anderson joins the conversation to explore the relationship between faith and national identity and what it means to keep the teachings of Jesus at the center of our Christian witness.
The Formed in Christ podcast is one part of a set of resources on white Christian nationalism.
Transcript
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Welcome to Formed in Christ: Faith, Fear, and the Way of Jesus, a podcast series from the General Commission on Religion and Race. In this series, we explore challenging questions about faith, identity, belonging, power, and discipleship. Our goal is not simply to identify distortions of the Christian faith, but to imagine a more faithful way forward, one rooted in the teachings of Jesus, grounded in Scripture, and committed to beloved community.
Today’s episode is called “When Faith and National Identity Become Confused.” In the United States, the overarching claim that America was founded as a Christian nation is said quite often. That claim shapes how people understand history, citizenship, political power, and the mission of the church.
Our primary question for this episode is: How does the belief that America is a Christian nation shape the way Christians understand their faith, citizenship, and mission? To help us explore that question, I’m joined by the Reverend Zach Anderson, a member of our GCORR board. Welcome, Zach. I’m grateful that you’re with us today.
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): Thanks, it’s great to be here.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): So, the phrase “Christian nation.” What does it mean? Let’s begin with that phrase itself. People can use “Christian nation” to mean very different things. For some, I know, it describes the faith of early settlers or the influence of Christian ideas. For others, it suggests that the nation has a special covenant with God, or that Christians should hold a privileged place in public life, and that privileged place looks a certain way. So when you hear the claim that America was founded as a Christian nation, what assumptions do you hear underneath that?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): Well, I think the issue that comes to mind is that, at face value, it seems like a very innocuous thing. It seems like a very positive thing. Sure, why wouldn’t we want to be like Jesus? And you think of the positive things. But when you look at how our nation has been in its history, it’s not the most ideal things that have happened. I think, sure, if we were all following the Golden Rule and loving each other and forgiving each other and turning the other cheek, great way to be a Christian nation. But unfortunately, everything this nation does as a secular government gets equated with Christianity. And people assume, then, that if this government does this, it’s the Christian way, when very often we see actions by our public officials and decisions made as a nation that are not in line with Christian theology, Christian understanding, biblical understanding. And people just put those together in their minds and essentially insert things into Scripture that aren’t there.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): And I think that distinction is important, right? Acknowledging the influence of Christianity in American history is not the same as declaring the nation itself Christian or treating one religious tradition as the measure of who fully belongs. And so, where does the idea of America as a Christian nation come from, and how does it compare with the teachings and ministry of Jesus?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): Well, I think so much of the narrative of the founding of this country was people seeking refuge from religious persecution. And so that becomes our narrative, true or not at times. It is what we’re taught from the youngest of ages, in the school systems in our country and in our churches as well. And in many cases, especially from the Midwest to the West, the first people to move and settle there, and the first buildings in many communities, were churches. Long before counties were even formed officially, there was a church there. And a lot of times it was our own Methodist tradition that was there on the forefront. So much of the early settlement of areas by European settlers became entwined with the church’s own history as well. And so I think that’s how we get there so quickly and so easily, with that being the accepted way things are.
People use the phrase “Christian nation,” but they never espouse Christian ideals in how they talk about things or in their decision-making. They don’t say, “You know, this is going awful, but we probably shouldn’t unilaterally attack this country, because that wouldn’t be what Jesus did.” Or you think about immigration, and how even in Scripture, in the Old Testament, it talks about welcoming the foreigner and offering hospitality. Those are not the ideals that people who espouse that we need to be a Christian nation are ever talking about.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah, and I think so often, especially those Christians who are practicing Christians, those who go to church on Sunday, who worship in any kind of regard or hold the Christian faith in any kind of regard, they forget that there is actual Scripture that talks about where our allegiance should be, right? And so I want to turn to Philippians 3:20, where Paul reminds the church that our citizenship is in heaven, or in the kingdom of God, and that our hope is centered in Jesus Christ. Paul wrote to believers, as we know, living within the Roman Empire, where citizenship carried status and protection and deep public meaning. Yet Paul directed their ultimate loyalty beyond the empire.
And so how does this passage, or really any passage in Scripture that talks about where our ultimate allegiance lies, challenge the assumption that a Christian’s primary identity is national rather than rooted in God’s kingdom?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): Yeah, I mean, I think this is something that most pastors going through the ordination process have struggled with. There’s that question about understanding the kingdom of God, using that language. You really had to think about it. It was a countercultural message, including what Paul is saying here, because the status of your citizenship was first and foremost what got you power and privilege and access to things. And I don’t know that it’s all that different from how people view things now. I mean, there’s this ideal that being a citizen of the United States of America is the greatest thing anybody could have in the world, but it’s not what Jesus espoused. It’s not what we see lived out in Scripture. In fact, he talks about starting at home and then working to the ends of the earth when it comes to our mission or ministry. And the early apostles all took off and went all over the place to spread the message. It didn’t say, “Please come with us back to Jerusalem.” It was establishing churches where the people were. There are so many examples of us being beyond any man-made border or political divisions.
It just seems so foreign, if you really spend time in Scripture, to think that I’d be loyal to my country first versus the greater in-breaking of God’s vision for the world. I mean, we pray the Lord’s Prayer and ask, “Thy kingdom come, thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven,” yet we don’t make decisions or vote or exercise our rights as citizens in a way that connects with that ideal.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah. Yeah, and I think that’s a helpful framework and, again, a really important distinction: Christians can love their neighbors, and we’re called to, and we’re called to participate in public life and seek the common good, but without confusing the nation with the kingdom of God.
And as we’ve seen, not just in the United States but globally, when Christianity becomes closely tied to a national identity, the gospel can begin to sound like a defense of the nation’s innocence. The actions, or even the conscience and character, of that nation can go unchecked, as the gospel becomes a defense of the nation’s innocence and power or way of life. What parts of the gospel do you think become harder to hear when Christian faith is fused with patriotism or national identity?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): You know, I think one of the prime examples I’ve seen firsthand with pastors I work with is this: because of the narrative that a certain leader of our country is so Christian, and that God ordained them to be our leader, people then connect everything they say as also godly. Pastors who preach on the Beatitudes are being accused of being too woke or, you know, too wimpy, to use that masculine idea that’s coming out in the midst of this kind of Christian nationalism going on, because it’s against the narrative being put forward by the leaders of the time. And so something as simple as the Beatitudes, which are a foundational understanding of Jesus for anybody who’s done any Bible study, becomes something that can’t actually be in the Bible. So we use our political narrative to say what is or isn’t in the Bible. It becomes the lens through which we read Scripture, when we should be viewing the world, and the decisions made in our governments and in our society, from the Bible, not vice versa.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah. Yeah. I remember when I served in the local church a few years ago, in another conference, one Sunday I had simply preached on the Great Commandment: love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength, and love your neighbor as yourself. And then I proceeded to enumerate who your neighbor is. And I thought, right, it’s a very basic, foundational teaching of Scripture. And one of the members of the congregation got upset because they did not want to hear who their neighbors were, right?
And it just reminds us that the teachings of Jesus call us to repentance and love of neighbor, care of people pushed to the margins, truth-telling, peacemaking, and costly solidarity. Not solidarity that’s rooted in comfort, but costly solidarity. And those commitments can challenge every nation, including our own.
How do distortions of Christianity, and specifically white Christian nationalism, make it harder for the church and faith communities to confront racism, exclusion, violence, or injustice within the nation?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): I think when we have this ideal of a Christian nation, it gives people the perception that everything the nation does is perfect, because God is perfect. And so anytime you confront or name the injustices in our society, people think you’re attacking not only the nation but God in that moment. But that’s not a Christian ideal either. I mean, the biblical ideal for conflict is to go to the issue and address it first with the person. And when you’re addressing a system, it’s naming it out loud. But because of that, the way their minds have connected everything, any type of accountability becomes an attack on faith, and you become outside the mainstream of Christianity, when it really should be the exact opposite of that. A truly Christian nation would be one that holds its leaders accountable by biblical standards and engages in conversation about what those ideals are, as opposed to taking in stride whatever the leaders tell us as theology, as opposed to our theology informing how we live.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah, yeah. I think at the root and at the heart of what you named, and you said it before, is this whole notion of idolatry, which is interwoven through all of Scripture. And it seems to be a common theme that when you name it from the pulpit, or when you’re teaching in a Bible study, or just naming it in congregations, people get really upset. It strikes a chord. So I’m wondering what you think about how white Christian nationalism plays into idolatry.
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): I’m sure this will make some people mad, but I just think about how important the placement of the flag of the United States of America is in our worship spaces, and how, if it ever gets moved or overshadowed, people get more upset about that than about whether the manger gets set out at Christmas time, or whether we get the right seasonal cloths up for the liturgical calendar. None of that seems to matter. But the minute that flag isn’t there on a certain secular holiday, it becomes a huge fight. And it just tells you that’s the importance. And they say, “Well, this is a free country, we need to honor that flag.” Well, I’m not crazy about the use of the Christian flag either, for its colonial reasons, but I’ve always advocated that if there’s going to be a flag of prominence in our sanctuary, at least make it the symbol of our faith as opposed to that. And so that becomes the most concrete example of that idolatry.
But I think any time we’re more concerned about something other than what God is calling us to becomes idolatrous. And I think the idea that our leaders can’t be wrong because they’re ordained by God to be there, that they were chosen by God to lead our country, becomes a problem too, because are you saying only the ones that agree with you are that way? You know, to say that God was part of that, and also, we just know that things change over time, and leaders will say things, and it’s so easy to slip a little bit of church language into a political speech to make people believe, “Well, that must be scriptural and godly.” That becomes idolatry in itself too: the leader themselves is the messenger of God, versus us having any sense of our own discernment on whether that’s right or wrong.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah. Yeah, and that may be one of the clearest tests of our allegiance: whether our faith is free to examine the nation honestly, and its leaders and their agendas, or whether we reshape the gospel to protect a national story. Right? Many Christians, and I would say, as we talked about before, across the world, feel genuine gratitude for their country and also want to remain faithful to Jesus.
The challenge, I think, is learning to order those loves rightly. And we talked about idolatry just a few minutes ago, and then you mentioned discernment, and I think that’s absolutely right. Discernment may involve noticing whose well-being we prioritize, whether we can tell the truth about our nation, and whether we see political opponents as enemies or as neighbors who still bear God’s image. I think discernment is a spiritual discipline and a practice that has to be done over and over and over again. But I think a lot of us who are Christian and practice the Christian faith don’t rightly know how to discern. Right? We’re always kind of waiting on someone to tell us, as opposed to praying together as a community, and practicing that prayer personally, and just sitting and allowing the Holy Spirit to speak to us through Scripture, through one another, and in other spaces about whether or not what we’re hearing, and who we’re listening to, is representative of who Jesus is.
What questions can Christians ask themselves to discern when healthy civic participation is becoming an idolatrous national loyalty?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): I think any time you get into a situation, if you ask yourself, “What’s the main motivation here?” that becomes a huge indicator of what’s driving your actions, your beliefs, your donations financially, all these things. If you have the ability to take a step back and really internally examine your motivation, it becomes a huge indicator of whether idolatry is taking over, whether you’re misplacing your nationalism over your faith.
And I think the other thing I always think about is this idea that one nation’s greater than another because of how Christian they are. The original bearers of the gospel were not from those countries that usually claim that. They’re from a whole different region of the world. And I think especially in denominations like the United Methodist Church, where we’re a global church, the dichotomy of being a member of a global church but saying, “My country’s better than yours and you should bow to us,” is troubling, because we say we’re one Christian body. And if you think ecumenically too, what’s the message there, saying that we’re better Christians than you because God’s blessed us more as a country and we’re the messengers of God, not you? That becomes problematic if you look at the scope of human history. And so I think you have to just take those pauses and say, “Okay, am I getting myself too entwined in something here? Is this really the best purpose for my time and energy and focus?” And I think that can help a lot of people. Of course, the practice is just taking a breath and pausing and not just going full bore on something.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah. Taking a breath and pausing, which is part of the practice of discernment, can by itself be prophetic in a society and in a culture that demands answers all of the time, right?
The practice of discernment and so many other spiritual practices remind us that kingdom citizenship is not an escape from the world. And I think when we look at Christian distortions like white Christian nationalism, it often champions an escape from the world. Kingdom citizenship is a way of living within the world with our deepest loyalty anchored in Christ.
Right. And so, as we close, I want to return to that central question that I asked in the beginning: How does the belief that America is a Christian nation shape the way Christians understand their faith, citizenship, and mission? And if you had one truth to leave with listeners today, what do you want them to remember from our conversation?
GUEST (REV. ANDERSON): I think the idea of how America being this great Christian nation influences us and affects us is the main idea of American exceptionalism: that everything’s got to be great and grand, and there’s a goal to meet or a status to achieve. That is contrary to really the long game of Christianity. We help in-break the kingdom of God here on this earth as an ongoing process. We’re not here to check boxes for some kind of reward. You know, there’s this idea of a very solitary salvation versus a communal salvation. It’s a theology of self versus a theology of community, and I think that should shift. If we really thought about the greater community worldwide, it would shift our whole thinking around these ideals. But as long as we continue to bring the ideals of Americanism into our Christianity, versus bringing our Christianity into Americanism, we’re going to run into that problem. It’s that very independent, self-driven, accomplishment-type mentality and theology. That’s rugged individualism.
HOST (REV. MUTETEKE): Yeah. Reverend Anderson, thank you so much for joining us today. Thank you for being with us.
Philippians 3:20, but not only Philippians 3:20, folks, all of Scripture reminds us that our deepest citizenship is in the kingdom of God, and our ultimate allegiance belongs to Jesus Christ. Nations can shape our stories, hold our loyalties, and give us opportunities to serve, but no nation is the kingdom of God, and no national identity can define the boundaries of Christ’s love. Jesus did not call his disciples to build a Christian nation. He called them to seek God’s kingdom, a kingdom made visible through love, justice, mercy, humility, truth, and service. Our task is not to claim divine ownership of a country or to secure privilege for ourselves. Our task is to love our neighbors, seek the common good, resist injustice, welcome the stranger, and bear faithful witness to Christ. May we have the courage to examine every allegiance, the humility to tell the truth about our history, and the faith to seek first the kingdom of God.
Thank you for listening to Formed in Christ: Faith, Fear, and the Way of Jesus. Grace and peace.